Badger Culling in 2024: A Devastating Step Backwards

The senseless and barbaric practise of badger culling has long been touted by farmers as a necessary strategy to curb the spread of bovine tuberculosis (bTB). In 2021 the government announced plans to phase out the slaughtering of this protected species, a decision that has now been overturned by Rishi Sunak. 

This U-turn is a devastating blow to conservationists, activists and scientists alike, and will allow the slaughter of thousands of badgers across the country, with plans to exterminate entire populations in some parts of the country. In today’s blog we’re going to be outlining why badger culling exists in the first place, why it’s so flawed (and cruel) as a strategy to combat bTB, and how we can fight this outrageous proposal by the government to allow it to continue.  

Why Badger Culling Exists:

Bovine tuberculosis poses a significant threat to livestock industries worldwide, including the United Kingdom, where the disease is endemic. Cattle movements, farming practices, and wildlife interactions all contribute to the persistence and spread of bTB. Badgers, considered reservoir hosts of the Mycobacterium bovis bacterium, have been implicated in disease transmission to cattle. Consequently, badger culling has been practised for over ten years as a management strategy, ostensibly to reduce bTB prevalence in both badger and cattle populations.

Why Badger Culling Is Controversial:

Badgers have been living in the UK for over 250,000 years. They’re a much beloved icon of the British countryside and are hailed as ecosystem engineers, rejuvenating soil and providing shelter and nesting sites for other wildlife, through their digging and foraging behaviour.

Despite its widespread adoption, mounting evidence tells us that badger culling is ineffective and even counterproductive in controlling bTB. In fact, culling has now killed half of Britain's badger population – over 210,000 badgers – but this hasn’t contributed to any discernible decline in cattle bTB cases. If that doesn’t scream ‘wildly misguided’ we don’t know what does. Several key factors contribute to this failure:

1. Incomplete Understanding of Disease Dynamics: Bovine tuberculosis is a multifaceted issue influenced by various ecological, epidemiological, and socio-economic factors. Simplistic approaches, such as targeting badgers, overlook the complexity of disease transmission pathways and fail to address root causes.

2. Disruption of Badger Social Structure: Culling disrupts badger social groups, leading to increased movement and potential disease spread as surviving badgers expand their territories into other areas.

3. Cattle-to-Cattle Transmission: While badgers may play a role in bTB transmission, 94% of bTB cases in cattle are a result of cattle-to-cattle contact. Inadequate biosecurity measures on farms, intensive farming practices, movement of infected cattle, and ineffective testing protocols contribute significantly to bTB persistence.

4. Ecological Consequences: Badgers are a keystone species in the UK ecosystem, playing crucial roles in biodiversity maintenance and ecosystem functioning. Indiscriminate culling can destabilise ecosystems, leading to unforeseen consequences for biodiversity and ecosystem services.

5. Mounting Evidence and Opposition: Scientific research has told us over and over that culling badgers simply doesn’t work, and that cattle measures are a more effective solution to preventing the spread of bTB. Wales and Scotland don’t cull badgers, yet they reduce bTB far more efficiently than we do in Britain. Also, the majority of adults strongly oppose badger culling - so why is taxpayer money being used to fund it?  

How to Fight Against the Cull:

There are several meaningful actions you can take to channel your rage into opposing the cull and advocating for badgers:

1. Raise Awareness: Scream it from the rooftops. Start conversations with individuals and communities to educate people on the reality and ramifications of badger culling. Utilise social media, public events, and educational campaigns to amplify your message.

2. Support Alternative Approaches: Advocate for the implementation of alternative strategies grounded in scientific evidence and ethical considerations. This may include improved biosecurity measures, vaccination programs for both badgers and cattle, and targeted testing and surveillance efforts.

3. Engage with Decision-makers: Lobby policymakers and government agencies to prioritise evidence-based approaches to bTB management and allocate resources towards sustainable solutions that protect both animal welfare and biodiversity.

4. Support Conservation Organisations: Donate to and volunteer with conservation organisations dedicated to protecting badgers and their habitats. These organisations play a crucial role in conducting research, implementing conservation initiatives, and advocating for policy change.

5. Support Opposition Movements: Make your voice heard by signing petitions and open letters that call on the government to uphold their previous promise to phase out the cull. You can sign the Badger Trust’s petition to end the cull here - they also have loads of great resources on their website if you’d like to get involved with the movement locally, read their extensive research into culling practises, or to write to your local MP.

Conclusion:

With half of the UK's beloved badger population already dead, we simply cannot allow the government to continue to bulldoze public opinion, scientific reason, and our natural ecosystems all in the name of a few misguided, trigger-happy farmers. Let's shout it from the rooftops and #endthecull in 2024.

Fighting for the rights and welfare of animals across the UK and Ireland is what we do, but we can't do it without you. To support our work, please consider donating, signing up to our newsletter, or following us on social media.